selm

I agree with this.

joe'smom

I know how aggravating it is to try finding just the right color on line. One time I sent a question to the Fat Quarter Shop inquiring about a fabric, and they offered to send me a swatch. If you're ever in this predicament again, it might be worth a try to request a few swatches from a shop that has a large selection of the marbles.

rryder

I actually prefer the 3rd from the left as it is between the two in the lattice and seems to be similar to the blue flowers in the floral between the lattice. To me, that makes the quilt pop a little more than using the one that is in the quilt itself.

Rob

Jeanette Frantz

I know how difficult it is to match fabrics, especially blues! I won't even make a suggestion as to which one you should choose. My son has an incredible ability in selecting/matching colors. If I'm going to match/coordinate colors, I get his input -- it's great having him close -- his dad had the same ability, but he passed away in 2004. My son is such a help to me!

Jane Quilter

I like the third from the left.

caspharm

What if you made a somewhat scrappy binding using fabrics 1 and 2?

Jingle

If it were me I would try to match a color from the floral.

Rose_P

I agree with bearisgray up to a point, but after so much time, even if they still make the fabric, the dye lot might make a difference. I once went around to 3 different stores trying to get the same forest green Kona cotton that I'd bought only months earlier, and each one was slightly different. Blues are harder to match than most other colors it seems to me.

Use the thrift sale list on this board to sell all the blues you bought (if you don't have other uses for them) and just keep looking. Even if you are seeing the exact one in a store, try to take it near a window because the natural light will show it differently than the store fluorescents. Take the top to the fabric store with you because you might have better luck seeing a good one that way than trying to match just the blue that's your first choice. It's beautiful and well worth going the extra distance.

JustAbitCrazy

Since it's for borders, I'd take off what's already on there and just go with one of the new, readily available fabrics that you've bought.