nativetexan

I prefer the yellow roof. looks more like a roof than the blue.

GrannieAnnie

To me, the blue snowflakes look too much like SKY. And actually, I'd consider using the dark brown in your door as a roof and then making the door a hunter green

thimblebug6000

I prefer the yellow roof block, all the colours pop for me. Of course they're both darling!

susie-susie-susie

Very cute block. I like the blue roof, but I also like the bow on the first barn. The blue outline looks neon to me. Do they all have to be the same? Maybe you should do half one color and half the other.
Sue

malindaann

I like the blue roof but both are lovely

joyce888

I vote for the blue. The yellow is too pale.

HillCountryGal

I like the yellow roof.

Looks like we're not much help!

tesspug

IMHO the blue roof doesn't look like it is attached. The brown of the top part of the barn does not recess behind the roof. It seems to be floating. They are very darling.

Cybrarian

Well I really like the yellow roof but I like all the other elements better in the 2nd one. I would choose the first one because the yellow seems to belong and the blue doesn't.

Pat625

BLUE!! Looks good in either though