Holice

stand back and squint your eyes or if you wear glasses, take them off and look

Don't spend too much time with the decision. Toss them in a pile, rearrange as your "gut" tells you to and go with it. You could spend the rest of the year trying to get "just the right" comgination. You can analyze and re-analyze and the last arrangement won't be any better than the first.
I taught classes in watercolor quilts and know how this works.

Holice

that should have been watercolor quilt classes.

Another factor here is the wide range of texture you have which can play as much a part as hue.

mjsylvstr

WOW...what are you making?

Ninnie

My favorite pattern of all K. I have made 2. I just sit in the middle of the floor, with my material around me. and pick up one, and go with what it looks like to me , fast. I do mine in lights, mediums, and darks. Never thought to do it in black and white. Can't wait to see it, know it will be beautiful!!

Auntie M

add me as another value challenged. but knowing your work it will be fantabulous...can't wait to see it.

kwhite

Ok looking on line this am for other examples and I am getting askired. I hope I can get it to move like I want it to.

mytwopals

Here's how I see them from lightest to darkest.

Lights - 7, 8, 21, 24 and 4
Mediums - 26, 16, 17, 18, 22, 23, 13, 14 and 25
Darks - 12, 15, 2, 3, 5, 19, 20, 6, 9, 1, 11 and 10

Obviously, the delineation between what is considered a light vs. medium and medium vs. dark is subjective. The lighter mediums could perhaps be considered lights and the lighter darks considered meduims to even out the 3 categories.

BellaBoo

Lights to me are:
6 7 8 9 24 20 19 12 11

Dark
1 5 6

All the others I see as Med.

gaigai

Hey!! You're making one without me?!! :-( :-( :hunf: :hunf:

zyxquilts

Squinting, this is how I read them:
Lights = 7, 8
Darks = 3,5,9,10
Mediums = all the rest

But I like what Hollis said too - just go for it & don't agonize about it too much! :wink: