I like the first one. It has a richer look to me.
peace

You have all been so helpful, thank you for sharing your ideas. I made a monumental decision.....I am making two quilts! I am making one for my future grandson ( that will be the second one and he hasn't even arrived yet- am I a little excited!!!). And I will make a second one to sell at our town wide yard sale. So there ya go. It's such an easy pattern and makes up really quickly. Thanks again to all!

If you can use both, that would be great!!

I like the 2nd better also - it provides the light that each quilt needs. Using both blocks in your quilt would work well.

I prefer the darker, but both will make good looking quilts. If you can't decide---why not alternate? the medium blue block beside a light blue block! You other blues will make the pieces match!

I like the both but for a baby I'd use the lighter one

Like both. Why choose just use both.

I think mixing them would make a more interesting quilt.

I think you could use both of these and it would give the quilt more interest.

I like both of the blocks and I agree, use both. It will be pretty.