Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   Lone Star Quilt gone wrong (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/lone-star-quilt-gone-wrong-t99549.html)

jillaine 02-14-2011 06:27 AM

Paper Princess,

Your profile quilt is lovely; can you please post a larger version of it (or point me to where I might see a larger version of it)? Thanks!

-- Jillaine

MTS 02-14-2011 06:28 AM

Another fabulous way to do a Lone Star (although limited to a 4x4 tp 6x6 grid) is using the Quiltsmart interfacing. It's quite ingenious, NO diamonds. Nada, not a one. And as long as you read the directions BEFORE you use it, you don't have to worry about any bias.

I've used it quite a few times, and it is most certainly worth the price in time and aggravation.

They also have mini size. Plus, if you get adventurous and really understand the concept, you could combine some of the foundations for larger stars.

I see that now they're selling it by the panel.

NAYY.

http://www.quiltsmart.com/khxc/index...ring=lone+star

I just wanted to add that even if you do it the Quiltsmart way, Jan Krentz's Lone Star book is worth every penny. Her directions and hints for settings are really helpful and spot on.

gal288 02-14-2011 06:30 AM

Good morning Jillaine, I'm sure you had a restless night over this one.

This board is an excellent example of good minds coming together.

MTS has the right idea, Because there is such a large discrepency in the sizes, go the muslin template way.

Size up each triangle, add a strip to the sides that is needed to bring it to the correct size, and MTS is also correct in making the strips a little longer to be trimmed later.

Starch the heck out of it, let it dry and then do the next one.

RuthFru 02-14-2011 06:56 AM

Your colors are sooooo beautiful it would be a shame to not use it. If you don't want to take it apart I would also try adding the strips as suggested by gal288. Good luck and please let us see how it turns out.

Willa 02-14-2011 07:23 AM

Love your colors! It will be beautiful when you get it fixed.

Prism99 02-14-2011 08:29 AM

As long as the star is closely quilted, washing won't be a problem even if you have used starch to re-block everything. Quilting will hold the alignments in place.

Other Sharon Schamber videos show how to make a firm pressing surface. She draws the correct shape on a piece of muslin, pins the muslin to the ironing surface, then blocks the piece to the marks on the muslin.

catmcclure 02-14-2011 08:36 AM


Originally Posted by jillaine
My fear about re-sewing is that the bias-- which is probably already stretched from my poor attempts to "make it fit gosh darn it!" -- is too far gone.
jss

If you draw off your diamonds the right size, you can pin your fabric to the grid and then steam press it.

Bias will reform itself if you pin it to the size it should be and then steam press it.

jillaine 02-14-2011 08:49 AM

Another related question: in one of her videos, Sharon spray-starches BEFORE pinning/stretching/reshaping; in another she does it AFTER pinning. As someone who has never used spray start in my quilting/sewing, and in this case, which should I do? Thanks.

Prism99 02-14-2011 09:07 AM

The water in spray starch relaxes the fibers so they can stretch.

I would say spray starch first if this is a piece where you will need to stretch it to meet the template marks. It will be easier to stretch the fabric if it is already wet.

Spray starch after if this is a piece that is too large for the template. Pin the dry piece to the template, spray to relax the fibers, then steam with the iron to get the fibers to shrink. (Drying wet fabric will tempt it to shrink.)

I don't think it makes a huge difference either way, just maybe a little easier.

IDquilter 02-14-2011 09:47 AM

They call it the 'lone star' because most of the time once you make one, you will never make another.

marciacp 02-14-2011 09:54 AM


Originally Posted by jillaine
Sigh...
Despite what I had believed to be accurate measuring, sewing and cutting, I clearly did something wrong because my lone-star diamonds are not "right". Now I have eight worthless 6x6 diamonds and I don't know what to do with them. I am horrified that I've done all this work and that I didn't catch the problem right away. I mean the diamonds are catty-wampus. Any suggestions for what to do with these, other than cremate them?

I didn't take time to read all the responses, but my 2 cents is
that I had this happen to me way back about 30 years ago
when I started quilting. I ended up re-cutting my strips and
what I learned is that the secret to a perfect lone star is in the cutting - not the piecing. When you make your strip sets,
you have to cut each strip with no wobble or curve. That means that you have to cut one or two strips, then place your
ruler on the previously cut line and trim a sliver off to give you a straight edge before you cut the next two or three strips. It is amazing how much one can get 'off' on making the strips straight, even though you are using a mat and cutter.

Then, when you sew your strips into sets, they have to be staggered on one end. I don't know why that matters, but it does. Then, if your strip sets have a bow in them, even a slight one, the diamonds will be off.

Finally, it is very important to cut each set with a true angle,
whether it be 45 or 60 degree angle, it must be true. Again,
after cutting two diamonds, you need to straighten the cut edge as described above, before cutting the next two, to make sure the diamonds are straight and have no bow or wobble.

I know this is long, and perhaps hard to understand, but if you follow these cutting steps, your diamonds will match perfectly. Oh, one more things is to never iron your strips sets, or your diamonds, but 'press' them with a dry iron,
which means to just put your iron on top of the sets and leave it there a few seconds - never iron back and forth because it will distort the bias.

This may be more confusing than helpful, but I have successfully made several loan stars after my fiasco, just
by following these methods of cutting and pressing.
Have a Great Day!
Marcia

jillaine 02-14-2011 10:44 AM

Marcia, your response is perfect and perfectly understandable. I actually wondered why Krentz recommended the little scrap strips in between strips and you've explained it beautifully. Lesson for next lone star I do (if I ever do one again...). Well, for any diagonal cutting. -- Jillaine

jamannix 02-14-2011 11:11 AM

Since they are mostly bias seams, try what one quilter above suggested.
Take each diamond to the ironing board, and place on a drawn diamond that is
the right size. Spray with starch to moisten. I use Mary Ellen's Best Press
since it leaves no residue. Pull the defective diamond until you approximate
the correct size and press.
I apologize if you have already done this ad nauseum.
If it didn't work then you should do what gal288 suggested with the sashing
and outlining suggestion.
Best of luck.
I found Jan Krentz's book on Lone Star Qlts from C&T publishing to be
very helpful.I at first thought it was wildly obsessive-compulsive, but it
works. She also has patterns that have diamonds around the outer edges
of the central Lonestar so if all else fails you could redo some of the
Lonestar diamonds over and use the misfits for the outer area.
I don't know how to upload pictures but your library might be able to get you the book. If you Google Jan Krentz Lone Star Quilts and beyond, the cover quilt shows a star with 8 edge diamonds. Her site charges $25 for the book.
Amazon has a used copy for $12.79 - Judy

ladyredhawk 02-14-2011 11:41 AM

wow I would find a way to make it work. i would be sick to do all the work and not be able to fix it. good luck

jillaine 02-14-2011 11:47 AM


Originally Posted by ladyredhawk
i would be sick to do all the work and not be able to fix it. good luck

Lady RedHawk, yes, it was my "illness" that led me to find this message board. -- Jillaine

marciacp 02-14-2011 01:17 PM


Originally Posted by jillaine
Marcia, your response is perfect and perfectly understandable. I actually wondered why Krentz recommended the little scrap strips in between strips and you've explained it beautifully. Lesson for next lone star I do (if I ever do one again...). Well, for any diagonal cutting. -- Jillaine

Thanks, Jillaine. I really encourage you to give this
another shot, maybe with fewer fabrics until you get
the hang of the technique. I wish I lived close to you, because I know I could show you in a New York minute
how to do it. Anyway, if you decide to try again, maybe
do it with 4 - 6 fabrics, and do a smaller size, (cut your
initial strips 1 1/2" x 22"), just to get the hang of it.
The smaller strip width and length are much easier to manage the first time around. You will end up with a
nice wall hanging if you cut your strips that size.

If you have any other questions if you decide to give it another shot, feel free to PM me and I will send you my phone number so we can talk it through. I feel very confident that once you make on successfully, you will
see how relatively easy it is and you will want to try a
larger one.

I actually taught a class on a Lone Star and one of my students made a queen size right off the bat. That
scared even me a little bit, because I thought it would be
too big to handle, but she did a great job and it turned out
well. Truthfully, it really is all in the cutting and pressing.
Have a Great Day!
Marcia

Rainbow 02-14-2011 01:30 PM


Originally Posted by quilter1943
Have you tried to reposition them? That might help. In the photo it looks like some of them that aren't next to each other might fit better with another one. Not sure if that makes sense. Move them around . . .

Thought this, too...WORTH A TRY !!

jeanneb52 02-14-2011 01:34 PM


Originally Posted by gal288
Jillaine, It's heartbreaking, but has happened to all of us at one time or another.

You could try this, it will change the look somewhat, but at least it may save you money and time.

Measure each of the legs of all the triangles, establish a mean measurement. Let's say is 14", for example.

1)Cut 24 (1") strips of the most neutral fabric 14".
2)Sew a strip to the long legs of each triangle, carefully pinning to make it fit the strip.Some will have to be stretched, some eased.
3) In the center, sew 1 strip to 1 length, then sew another triangle to that strip, and repeat.

I did a quick scale in EQ to give you a visual. It's going to be work but less than ripping out all those squares. The pink strips are the adjustment.

Great idea...we all have to cheat once in awhile.

JUNEC 02-14-2011 03:56 PM

Wish I could help - but I am bookmarking this page - to review in the future - great tips

San Diego Quilter 02-14-2011 04:18 PM

I would separate the large diamonds and applique them on a dark background - sort of a "broken star" approach. You could even quilt some lines radiating out from the center. It's a star on the move...the "big bang"!

Everyone is right....much too pretty to burn!

IBQUILTIN 02-14-2011 04:26 PM

I'd try rechecking all of my seam allowances. They sure make a difference in a lot of patterns. Make sure they are exactly 1/4 inch

k9dancer 02-14-2011 04:53 PM


Originally Posted by gal288
Jillaine, It's heartbreaking, but has happened to all of us at one time or another.

You could try this, it will change the look somewhat, but at least it may save you money and time.

Measure each of the legs of all the triangles, establish a mean measurement. Let's say is 14", for example.

1)Cut 24 (1") strips of the most neutral fabric 14".
2)Sew a strip to the long legs of each triangle, carefully pinning to make it fit the strip.Some will have to be stretched, some eased.
3) In the center, sew 1 strip to 1 length, then sew another triangle to that strip, and repeat.

I did a quick scale in EQ to give you a visual. It's going to be work but less than ripping out all those squares. The pink strips are the adjustment.

I think this is a brilliant solution.

busygranny 02-14-2011 05:03 PM

Colors are beautiful---u can't throw it away. Leave it sit for awhile and then go bac k and try to rescue it.

galvestonangel 02-14-2011 05:23 PM


Originally Posted by Prism99
It doesn't look that bad to me. I would block each piece to size using Sharon Schamber's spray starching technique. Here is a link to her video on how to stretch a block (she also has one on how to shrink a block):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQkF02vpVuw

The hardest part of doing this is drawing an accurate template for blocking purposes.

I agree, check out Sharon's tut and startch and reposition, I think that would work. I would try that before ripping and resewing which will be disasterous with bias edges.

butterflywing 02-14-2011 06:45 PM


Originally Posted by ktbb
Or, separate each of the dimonds and applique them to a solid background and add sashing, etc to enlarge the star design and hide the discrepancies in size...your own design.

that's what i'd do, using black bias 'leading'. you'd have to go all the way around each of the star pieces, but that should be okay. i think it would have the look of stained glass. you only need a very narrow strip between the pieces to make it right.

(i would never have the patience to unsew and resew. i give credit to those who do.)

jillaine 02-14-2011 07:04 PM

Update: trying the starch-blocking approach first. Three diamonds down; eight more to go. (I only have room to do one diamond at a time and it takes about 20 minutes to pin, spray, iron, spray, iron, spray, iron; then I let it sit for an hour.)

If this doesn't work, I'll next try the "cheating" approach suggested by Peg.

KarenBarnes 02-14-2011 07:20 PM

It looks kind of like my first. Mine was actually cut at the wrong diagonal. I had enough fabric to make another but still have the miscut diamonds that someday I will just sew in another pattern for a scrappy quilt! Someday...after I finish all the other fun ones that I've done over the years and plan to do!

Moondancer 02-14-2011 07:57 PM

If they absolutly dont fit and look good dont use them as a large star just use the diminds on their own put binding between them and have them as floating dimaonds. as last resort.

jitkaau 02-14-2011 08:03 PM

If you don't want to re - sew to make sure the seams are all the same width, try cutting them up ,add a few solids and other stuff and make a crazy patchwork quilt that will look fine.

jillaine 02-15-2011 06:07 AM


Originally Posted by IDquilter
They call it the 'lone star' because most of the time once you make one, you will never make another.

I just now saw this; somehow missed it. VERY funny.

By the way, I'm creating a tutorial from this experience.

-- Jillaine

vschieve 02-15-2011 07:25 AM

Marciacp,
I don't know where Crowley TX is but next time you teach a class on this I think it would be worth the drive from Austin to attend!!! I have never attempted the Lone Star but your advice sounds perfect.

jillaine 02-15-2011 10:17 AM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by vschieve
Marciacp,
I don't know where Crowley TX is but next time you teach a class on this I think it would be worth the drive from Austin to attend!!! I have never attempted the Lone Star but your advice sounds perfect.

Three hours, ten minutes.

marciacp 02-15-2011 10:21 AM


Originally Posted by vschieve
Marciacp,
I don't know where Crowley TX is but next time you teach a class on this I think it would be worth the drive from Austin to attend!!! I have never attempted the Lone Star but your advice sounds perfect.

Crowley is only about 2 hrs north of Austin, straight up
I-35 North. We are right off the freeway, about 5 miles
South of Ft. Worth. You are so kind to say you would
come up here to take a class from me. It seems like
the quilt shops in our area are pretty much saturated
with teachers and most of the quilters in the area have
already taken about every class they want to. So, not
much need for classes, it seems (at least not the shops
closest to me). I have also taught classes in my home,
so if there were enough interest, I could do that.

To tell the truth, I could easily teach the technique in one day, because it is all in the cutting and pressing. However,
I have found that most students that are learning a new method like to have several classes so they can have someone to guide them through the whole process.

I do like what one teacher I have just learned about does - she teaches an all day class on the technique of cutting and making a block (Judy Neimeyer's techniques), then she makes herself available at the shop for three days the next week for anyone that wants to come and continue making the quilt, with her there to answer questions, etc. She charges $10.00 for each day someone comes for additional help. I think that is a great idea, and one I might use if I teach another class like the Lone Star that is more challenging. If I do teach another class, I'll let you know.
Have a Blessed Day!
Marcia

vschieve 02-15-2011 10:51 AM

Thanks to you all helping with my Texas geography! Now I know!! Keep me posted on Lone Star quilting. Once I retire from full time job I hope to make it to more classes. Did one two weeks ago in Fredericksburg, at Pocketful of Poseys. We did "Circle A Round" where you cut out circles and sew them into another circle you cut in your base fabric. Pretty awesome. With that I have a UFO to get back to plus one more Circle quilt in my brain, another future project. I will get to a Lone Star though, one of these days!

Rettie V. Grama 02-15-2011 06:23 PM

Place the corners (not the points) together, then when folded diamond over diamond cut the center points to match the smallest diamond.

neeng 02-15-2011 06:57 PM


Originally Posted by ktbb
since you;ve got so many bias edges you could try starching and sizing the diamonds to shape by pinning them to a board for drying..draw out the shape they should be then pin to that size after they're wet with starch and let dry...

Or, separate each of the dimonds and applique them to a solid background and add sashing, etc to enlarge the star design and hide the discrepancies in size...your own design.

Both good ideas. I would try the starch first, and if that doesn't do it, then use these over a background as suggested, and start with new ones for your quilt.

franie 02-15-2011 07:04 PM

OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

lclang 02-15-2011 09:18 PM

Don't dispair. I did a Lone Star and pieced it twice on the machine and once by hand before I was satisfied. Turned out to be a very nice quilt but I shudder when I look at diamond shapes to this day!

jillaine 02-15-2011 10:04 PM

Update. I'm halfway through blocking my eight lone-star diamond arms. Some are going worse than others. I am following closely S. Shambers (?) video instructions.

One of the things she does not cover is how much of a difference can you have before you cannot use the blocking/starching method to "shrink" a piece.

I have tried very hard to get the shrinking results she demonstrated, but it's not going well. many puckers (although they ARE starched to hell and back.)

-- Jillaine

Mattee 02-16-2011 06:25 AM

Please take another look. I really think you can save yourself a lot of trouble if you re-sew just a few seams for those diamonds that are much too large. You can pick them out just by eyeballing. You could also use a ruler to quickly check their width, but some look much to large in the pic.


Originally Posted by jillaine
Update. I'm halfway through blocking my eight lone-star diamond arms. Some are going worse than others. I am following closely S. Shambers (?) video instructions.

One of the things she does not cover is how much of a difference can you have before you cannot use the blocking/starching method to "shrink" a piece.

I have tried very hard to get the shrinking results she demonstrated, but it's not going well. many puckers (although they ARE starched to hell and back.)

-- Jillaine



All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:16 PM.