I like D the most. It really caught my eye. It is going to be a beautiful quilt.
Sue

I think B really stands out at least to me.

I like B best.

I say A , although I looked at each one carefully a few times.

It is modern and each motif shows up well against its background.

i like A and B.

I like A and D, but it's really about what YOU like!

A
and you're right, it's masculine...but what's wrong with that?

But your Mom was right too, B looks good.

The first one is my preference.

The first one is bold, the second one is Christmasy, but I feel the last two looks washed out to me.

B - I like the addition of red.