My choice would be the red.

Gold - elegant. It stands out better. While the red is pretty, it is sort of busy. But - the white center makes it look like a wreath!

Definitely the gold with the lovely Christmas fabrics.

Gold center

I think I like the one with the gold center the best. And I think it's very pretty.

THE CONTRAST FROM THE GOLD IS THE BEST BUT I THINK I WOULD TRY A DIFFERENT SHADE OF GOLD. THE RED IS OK BUT I THINK I WOULD TRY A DIFFERENT AGAIN NOT THE SAME AS IN THE BODY. NUMBER 3 MAKES IT LOOK THE SAME OR ALL ONE COLOR. THE GOLD AND WHITE MAKE THE CENTER STAND OUT AND I DON'T CARE FOR THE WHITE AT ALL. I FEEL A LIGHTER AND A PLAINER OR VARIED SHADE WOULD BRING MORE CONTRAST TO THE PIECE. SO I WOULD SAY THE GOLD IS BETTER BUT NOT THE BEST. BUT WHAT IS YOUR CHOICE AND HOW DO YOU INTEND TO USE IT

I like the first one.

I love #1 and #3

I like the gold
LC

I'd pick the red one, but wonder how it'd look with a solid or simpler red?