MacThayer

I'd make as many as I needed for whatever I wanted. Maybe you could do each one a little differently, like making the tree skirt one round. Perhaps it wouldn't be so difficult to cut into if it looked (to your mind) more like a tree skirt. Or change one of the colors - red and green or red and gold would make a nice tree skirt. There's no reason to stop at one if you like the pattern. It's a lovely pattern, btw.

GrammaNan

Me too! ...

AnnT

It's beautiful as a table topper. I'd seriously consider making all three. Love the pattern!

petpainter

I would finish it as a tree skirt, then if you decide to still make another, go for it! I, too, need a bigger skirt for MY tree, too, so that may be swaying me decision.

Pink Dogwood

It's beautiful and will look great for whatever you decide. I do understand about not wanting to cut it for the tree skirt. That would be my problem, but it would be a great tree skirt. Good luck with your decision. Whatever it is it will be the right one!!

ManiacQuilter2

It does look very nice on your table.... Hmmm.....

HillCountryGal

Trust your instincts.
Your first thought was this is going to be a Christmas tree skirt. Finish it that way. Then, make how many others you want to coordinate as a table cloth and/or lap quilt.

VERY pretty by the way.

scrapinmema

This is beautiful and would make two more.

mrs. fitz

IMO the design would be "lost" as a tree skirt. It's a great pattern, love your fabrics.

MargeD

It does make a beautiful table topper, so I might be tempted to make another one as a tree skirt.