Tie vs stitch
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Inverness, Florida Lived in states MA (born/graduated) RI (twice) CA (3 times) MO (3 times) KY VA
Posts: 376
![Default](/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Does anyone here tie their quilts?
Is it considered less of a quilt if it's not machine quilted or at least hand quilted?
Yarn vs DMC thread vs crochet thread if you do tie?
Do tied quilts hold up for a long time?
I'm new to all this but I have 4 finished tied quilts over the last 2 months with 4 more tops ready to sandwich. My goal is 10 by Christmas and then work on one for me.
Is it considered less of a quilt if it's not machine quilted or at least hand quilted?
Yarn vs DMC thread vs crochet thread if you do tie?
Do tied quilts hold up for a long time?
I'm new to all this but I have 4 finished tied quilts over the last 2 months with 4 more tops ready to sandwich. My goal is 10 by Christmas and then work on one for me.
![Smile](https://cdn.quiltingboard.com/images/smilies/smile.png)
#3
Super Member
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: West Texas
Posts: 2,073
![Default](/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I like DMC or crochet thread. I do not prefer yarn. It is harder to pull through and turns to a fuzz ball after a few washings.
The important thing with tying quilts is to have a secure knot. I work with charity quilts, and some of the ones that come in are tied with granny knots. I can pull them out with no trouble, so they will never stand up to normal use or washing.
Dayle
The important thing with tying quilts is to have a secure knot. I work with charity quilts, and some of the ones that come in are tied with granny knots. I can pull them out with no trouble, so they will never stand up to normal use or washing.
Dayle
#4
Power Poster
Join Date: May 2008
Location: MN
Posts: 24,581
![Default](/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I have some very old, very well used quilts that were tied.
The important things to me with a tied quilt -
1) The knots are secure
2) Depending on the batting/filler/middle - there are enough knots to hold it together and to keep the middle layer from shifting around - if one is using flannel or warm and natural batting, for example, one knot every 10 inches would probably be adequate. If using a fiber that is sort of 'loose' - a knot every four inches - read the packaging label
3) I prefer the knots to be 'arranged' - not scattered willy-nilly. It probably doesn't affect/afflict the utility value of the item, but I like the knots to be arranged in fairly straight lines and fairly consistently spaced.
The important things to me with a tied quilt -
1) The knots are secure
2) Depending on the batting/filler/middle - there are enough knots to hold it together and to keep the middle layer from shifting around - if one is using flannel or warm and natural batting, for example, one knot every 10 inches would probably be adequate. If using a fiber that is sort of 'loose' - a knot every four inches - read the packaging label
3) I prefer the knots to be 'arranged' - not scattered willy-nilly. It probably doesn't affect/afflict the utility value of the item, but I like the knots to be arranged in fairly straight lines and fairly consistently spaced.
#5
![Default](/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I LOVE the process of tying a quilt. Call me silly. Plus, the quilts come out so soft, not stiff like some "over-quilted" machine quilting that I have done. I use two or three strands of DMC floss. I have used yarn and it is soooo very hard to pull through. The floss makes it a breeze.
#8
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Inverness, Florida Lived in states MA (born/graduated) RI (twice) CA (3 times) MO (3 times) KY VA
Posts: 376
![Default](/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Thanks everyone. I was beginning to think tied quilts were the lazy way of doing them. Personally I like them better. :-)
#10
Super Member
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Pacific NW
Posts: 9,528
![Default](/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I think it's a matter of personal preference, and a tied quilt does not make it less of a quilt. This gets into Quilt Police territory, IMO. If anyone tells you it's not a "real" quilt, just turn and walk away, lol. The only opinion that counts is yours.
I've always been more a fan of quilting vs tying, but I saw a quilt that Kaffe Fassett did that was tied with French knots - and it was drop-dead GORGEOUS. Now I'm contemplating which one of my unfinished tops I should tie with French knots! lol!
I've always been more a fan of quilting vs tying, but I saw a quilt that Kaffe Fassett did that was tied with French knots - and it was drop-dead GORGEOUS. Now I'm contemplating which one of my unfinished tops I should tie with French knots! lol!
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Butterfli19
General Chit-Chat (non-quilting talk)
3
10-19-2013 05:41 AM