seasaw2mch

I like the 3rd choice but I'm not sure I would put the extra blue around the outside. I like it with just the brown.

Annz

I like choice #2. I think the thicker colored squares goes better with the border. #1 in my opinion doesn't look as good because the first border (before the keys) is too thick and makes it look like (with the outer border) the keys are in jail or something. #3 looks nice too but it looks like it was done because it was quick and easy. Therefore I would choose #2. Just my biatchy opinion tonight.

amazon

I like # 2. Very nice :thumbup:

IBQUILTIN

I love choice #1 too. And piano keys aren't so bad, just strip piecein the colors you want, cut into sections, and sew them together. Not so bad.

Dee

My choice is number 3.

Myraquilt

I like #1 first, then #2. I think #3 looks too blah.

JudithAnn

I vote for...................NUMBER ONE!!!!!

bjdemir

I like #'s 2 and 3 but can't decide which one I like best.

Quilting Grandma

I love the piano keys. I have done several and love the way they look. Good Luck.

nlgh

Go with the one you like best. All 3 look good in the small pictures, but what do you think when you look at the real mccoy?