Rolling Cart Comparison: Ikea Raskog vs. Target Room Essentials
08-19-2015, 07:36 PM
#1
Super Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Rhode Island
Posts: 1,663
Rolling Cart Comparison: Ikea Raskog vs. Target Room Essentials
For quite a while, I had been wanting one of those adorable turquoise Raskog carts from Ikea for my sewing room. I finally broke down about a month ago and ordered one. Since I'm not close enough to Ikea to just go and pick one up, I had to pay a shipping cost of $10 in addition to the cost of the cart, which is $29.99, making it a total of $39.99.
Last week while wandering through Target, I saw their version of the rolling cart, which is part of the Room Essentials line. The carts are available in either white or grey, at a price of $39.99. Hmmm... I wondered... is sure does look a lot like the Ikea cart, I wonder if it's the same quality? I wanted another cart to use for my knitting/crocheting stuff in another room, so I couldn't resist buying the Target cart, too. (It's actually on sale this week for $35.99.)
So, here's my unscientific appraisal of both carts, in case anyone is interested!
The size of the shelves on both carts is exactly the same – each shelf is 16” wide and 12” deep. The sides on the Ikea cart are higher at 3.5”; the sides on the Target cart are only 2.5”. The overall height of the Ikea cart, from the floor to the top of the top shelf's side, is 31”. The Target cart is 27” from the floor to the top of the top shelf's side, and the handles add another 3” for an overall height of 30”.
Both carts have a sort of basketweave-like bottom on each shelf, so in either case if you have little items, you'll need to line the shelves with something to prevent things from falling through. Both units have the same type of casters, and both are very easy to roll about.
Generally speaking, the Ikea cart is quite a bit heavier when empty, and the quality and strength of the metal seems better. (It took some muscle for me to carry it upstairs!) The Ikea cart was also much fussier to assemble but is sturdier. It has some seriously large nuts and bolts holding the shelves onto the sides. The shelves on the Target cart are simply attached with shorter fat Phillips-head screws, but without the extra hardware of the Ikea cart. The Target cart has the handles on top for ease of movement. The Ikea cart needs to be moved by pushing or pulling on the side rails or the shelves.
If I were going to buy another cart, my preference would definitely be the Ikea! But the lighter-weight Target cart might be better for some folks. I think the cart is a seasonal item (the Room Essentials line is heavily marketed toward dorm decor), so I'd make a beeline over there if you want one!
Here are a couple of photos for comparison. Sorry they're a little blurry, they were taken with my phone.
Last week while wandering through Target, I saw their version of the rolling cart, which is part of the Room Essentials line. The carts are available in either white or grey, at a price of $39.99. Hmmm... I wondered... is sure does look a lot like the Ikea cart, I wonder if it's the same quality? I wanted another cart to use for my knitting/crocheting stuff in another room, so I couldn't resist buying the Target cart, too. (It's actually on sale this week for $35.99.)
So, here's my unscientific appraisal of both carts, in case anyone is interested!
The size of the shelves on both carts is exactly the same – each shelf is 16” wide and 12” deep. The sides on the Ikea cart are higher at 3.5”; the sides on the Target cart are only 2.5”. The overall height of the Ikea cart, from the floor to the top of the top shelf's side, is 31”. The Target cart is 27” from the floor to the top of the top shelf's side, and the handles add another 3” for an overall height of 30”.
Both carts have a sort of basketweave-like bottom on each shelf, so in either case if you have little items, you'll need to line the shelves with something to prevent things from falling through. Both units have the same type of casters, and both are very easy to roll about.
Generally speaking, the Ikea cart is quite a bit heavier when empty, and the quality and strength of the metal seems better. (It took some muscle for me to carry it upstairs!) The Ikea cart was also much fussier to assemble but is sturdier. It has some seriously large nuts and bolts holding the shelves onto the sides. The shelves on the Target cart are simply attached with shorter fat Phillips-head screws, but without the extra hardware of the Ikea cart. The Target cart has the handles on top for ease of movement. The Ikea cart needs to be moved by pushing or pulling on the side rails or the shelves.
If I were going to buy another cart, my preference would definitely be the Ikea! But the lighter-weight Target cart might be better for some folks. I think the cart is a seasonal item (the Room Essentials line is heavily marketed toward dorm decor), so I'd make a beeline over there if you want one!
Here are a couple of photos for comparison. Sorry they're a little blurry, they were taken with my phone.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
butterflywing
General Chit-Chat (non-quilting talk)
50
03-02-2010 08:07 PM
