amma

The circles do make the quilt pop, but I do like the traditional, also. Either way you will have a beautiful quilt :D

quilt addict

Thanks for all your thoughts. I had to make the pictures small to get them to upload to the site.

I have printed out each of them so I can think about them some more.

Hope everyone is having a great Labor day.

Lisa

Knot Sew

try posting them big.......I do sometimes, it takes a long while sometimes 5 min.........I hate to say without seeing them better

jbsstrawberry

I like the top one better as well. To me it blends better that way...the circles are kinda bold, for me anyway. But like its been said already, its really what's more striking to you that will be the best way.

Cathe

I like the top one. It has more "movement." :)

DebJ

I prefer the top one. I agree it has more movement, your eyes tend to roam all over the quilt. The bottom the background just disapears, at least it does in the photo.