Patty44

Must be,I just thougght the black really made that block stand out. Maby she sould make one of each.Ha

tslowery

I might get good after several and decide to do 12 of each would that be ok for the swap are is everyone saying Gosh do Not give me one of those... :oops: :roll: :cry: :cry:

collettakay

I think they'd be great for the swap.

sewjoyce

They're both great -- but I like the one with the white background the best! But our opinions really don't matter -- which one do YOU like the best??

tslowery

Well I kind of like the black but I love black. My daughter said white because she said do not give me black (she has a black and white dog and he sheds white hair :lol: :lol: ) she said make 12 of each and then you will get 24 different ones back. :roll: :roll:

monica4patience

I prefer the black background. But that may be because I just completed a Friendship quilt for my daughter that used a black background with white swirls and stars...so your black block is familiar to me!

After making 36 blocks I would recommend pressing your seams open. It makes it much easier to make the points. I ended up just outline quilting around the stars.

~Monica

Kyiav10

White background is my favorite.

And definately keep trying!! You will be so proud of yourself when it is all together!!

Kyia

BlueChicken

What we like is an extremely personal choice.... I'm the same as your daughter, I avoid too much black purely because I have four black and white dogs (who only shed their white hairs of course) and two creamy coloured cats. So I prefer the white background.

But... keeping in mind these are for the swap, I think either would do just fine, honestly! :-)

Learning to pick what YOU like, and ignoring the rest of the world, takes time. ;-) Don't be too hard on yourself.

Evelynquilts

they are both pretty, but I like the white best,,,, :lol:

Ninnie

I like the white one best , but both of them are great.