aggie

Plaid. The blue looks better with just one square showing but I think the plaid would add more interest to the whole quilt. The blue would seem too bright and plain for an entire quilt. Butr then again what do I know? LOL

judyyoungs

Blue.

Judith

I vote for the plaid. I love plaids!

rona thickpenny

yes blue first I think .

KandiKane

I like the plan blue ..

quiltingcousin

I think the little voice you heard in selecting the blue was "right on" as I too prefer the blue with red binding. I think so many times we question ourselves when "our gut" automatically leads us down the right path. It's going to be stunning!

callie

Definitely blue

grandmaqltz

The plaid brings that fabric out to the outside and makes the whole piece together, instead of a bulls-eye effect in the center of the star.

sewing4kix

The solid brightens it up but the plaid gives it an older look. I vote plaid!

dixiechunk

The plaid, everything but the plaid reads as a tone on tone, the plaid adds some oomph. JMHO