Really pretty!! Thanks for showing us! Can't even tell that it's your first attempt - looks like a winner to me! :thumbup:

Really nice :thumbup:

Your topper is beautiful. You should never say never :-) keep woring on paper piecing you'll get better and beter until you feel confident to do the new York beauty.

Jan you did a beautiful job on your first project, I think you should just go for it and make the new York beauty, you just proved you are more than capable of doing it.
It is better to try than regret it later, but I more than think you will do a beautiful job.
GOD bless.

I agree. NY beauty is overrated on its difficulty.

Very nice!!!!!!! I'm impressed!!!!!!!!!!!

Very pretty.

Beautiful !! :thumbup:

Nice work! Striking, the contrast between the white, red and green!

OOOH you did a wonderful job. I love Love to paper Piece and there are so many site you can get free patterns.
have fun