BizzieLizzie

I like the combination with fabric no 2. That gives it more of a country feel to me. Whatever you choose, it will turn out real nice. Best wishes.

Jan T

Number one drabs it down and number two brightens it up. Just depends on which way you are leaning. I'd choose number one. Your blocks are wonderful. I would use 2 inch sashing between the blocks, and make a stop border of the same fabric around the edges. Then do a checkerboard border of scrappy squares or 2 x 4 inch piano keys. You are definately on the right track. Your neautrals really pull the scraps together for a cohesive feel. BRAVO for you stepping out of your box and trying something new.

Suzanne in VT

I like the #2 best and WOULD NOT put a border on it. I love scrap quilts, like yours, that are border-less. "If" you do put a border on, I'd make it a scrappy border and not a plain one.

Suzanne in VT

justlooking

As you can see, everyone has their own opinion! Go with what you like.

kimscruzer

I vote for #1

Stitchnripper

I love your scrappy quilt. I like #1 and might consider the same as the border and binding. Just my thoughts. I did a scrappy without sashing but made the border, binding and backing all the same and I love the way it turned out. But, it is your quilt, so do what pleases you the most. And then please post a picture of the finished product so we can admire it.

jtquilts

I love the dark brown of #1. To me the blocks pop more with the dark. Love the look!

Winnemay

Make it a true scrappy and sew all the squares together with no sashing and an outside border to finish it off!

Yooper32

I like #2 for sashing and would wait to decide border until you have all the blocks done and sashed.

roadrunr

I like # 3 the best, but the other two colors would also work. I also like scrappy quilts and am planning on making quite a few scrappy quilts. But not all scrappy quilts look scrappy, if you know what I mean.